Smart Locks vs Traditional Deadbolts: We Tested Both for 6 Months
Are smart locks actually more convenient? Are they secure? We installed both types on our test doors for six months. Here's the verdict.
BestElectronicsReviewed.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
We installed smart locks and traditional deadbolts on identical doors and lived with both for six months. The results surprised us.
The Contenders
- August Wi-Fi Smart Lock (4th Gen) — $229, Wi-Fi built-in, works with Alexa/Google/HomeKit
- Schlage Encode Plus — $299, Apple Home Key support, built-in keypad
- Wyze Lock Bolt — $43, fingerprint reader, Bluetooth only
What We Learned
Convenience: Smart Locks Win Decisively
Auto-lock when you leave, auto-unlock when you arrive, temporary codes for dog walkers and cleaners, checking lock status from bed. After a week, going back to keys feels like going back to a flip phone.
Security: It's a Tie
Smart locks use the same ANSI Grade 1 or 2 deadbolt mechanisms as traditional locks. The "hacking" risk is theoretical — in practice, burglars kick doors, they don't hack Bluetooth.
Reliability: One Gotcha
The August lock's Wi-Fi connection dropped 3 times over 6 months, requiring a reboot. The Wyze (Bluetooth only) never dropped. The Schlage was rock-solid. Battery life averaged 5-8 months across all three.
Best Value
The Wyze Lock Bolt at $43 is the smartest buy for most people. Fingerprint unlock is faster than any app, and Bluetooth means no Wi-Fi dependency. The only trade-off: no remote access (you need to be within Bluetooth range).
Read our full smart lock guide →
As an Amazon Associate, BestElectronicsReviewed earns from qualifying purchases.
Recommended Products
Top picks from our buying guides
Related Articles
USB4 and What It Means for External GPUs
USB4 promises bandwidth that could make external GPUs viable for gaming laptops. Here is the current state of eGPU technology and where it is heading.
NewsWalkie-Talkies in 2026: Still Useful or Completely Obsolete?
In an era of unlimited cell plans, who needs walkie-talkies? Surprisingly, a lot of people. Here's when they still beat your phone.
NewsRight to Repair in 2026: Which Brands Support Self-Repair?
Right to repair legislation is expanding, and some brands are embracing it. Here's which companies let you fix your own devices and which still fight it.